Analysis of the reporting of search strategies in Cochrane systematic reviews.

TitleAnalysis of the reporting of search strategies in Cochrane systematic reviews.
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2009
AuthorsYoshii A, Plaut DA, McGraw KA, Anderson MJ, Wellik KE
JournalJournal of the Medical Library Association : JMLA
Volume97
Issue1
Pagination21-9
Date Published2009 Jan
ISSN1558-9439
KeywordsAbstracting and Indexing as Topic; Bibliometrics; Databases, Bibliographic; Guideline Adherence; Guidelines as Topic; Humans; Information Storage and Retrieval; Medical Subject Headings; Meta-Analysis as Topic; Periodicals as Topic; Quality Control; Review Literature as Topic
AbstractBACKGROUND: The Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions provides instructions for documenting a systematic review's electronic database search strategy, listing elements that should be in the description. Complete documentation of the search strategy allows readers to evaluate the search when critically appraising a review's quality. OBJECTIVE: The research analyzed recently published Cochrane reviews to determine whether instructions for describing electronic database search strategies were being followed. METHODS: Eighty-three new reviews added to the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews in the first quarter of 2006 were selected for analysis. Eighteen were subsequently excluded because their searches were conducted only in the specialized registers of Cochrane review groups. The remaining sixty-five reviews were analyzed for the seven elements of an electronic database search strategy description listed in the Cochrane Handbook, using dual review with consensus. RESULTS: Of the 65 reviews analyzed, none included all 7 recommended elements. Four reviews (6%) included 6 elements. Thirty-two percent (21/65) included 5 or more elements, with 68% (44/65) including 4 or fewer. Three included only 2 elements. The 65 reviews represented 41 different Cochrane review groups. CONCLUSION: The instructions from the Cochrane Handbook for reporting search strategies are not being consistently employed by groups producing Cochrane reviews.
DOI10.3163/1536-5050.97.1.004
Alternate JournalJ Med Libr Assoc