Appraisal of: O'Leary N, Tiernan E, Walsh D, Lucey N, Kirkova J, Davis MP. The pitfalls of a systematic MEDLINE review in palliative medicine: symptom assessment instruments. Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2007; 24(3): 181-184.

Short description: 

The authors describe the usefulness of the related articles link in PubMed as part of a systematic MEDLINE review. Of 1181 citations identified, through a PubMed search, 10 articles met the indusion criteria. as did a further 21 articles identified through hand-searching the references of the 10 articles. The PubMed related articles link of the 10 articles yielded 15% of all reports finally included in the systematic review. The authors suggest that it is a useful tool in PubMed for revietrieving complex evidence.

Limitations stated by the author(s): 

No limitations stated by the authors.

Limitations stated by the reviewer(s): 
Different numbers are described in the result section: references that met the inclusion criteria and references finally included in the systematic review. This selection process is not clearly documented and it is not clear how many references finally included in the systematic review are identified through which source.
Study Type: 
Single study